Coating Atlas

How we rank shops

Shops on each city page are ordered by the Coating Atlas score. It starts from facts we can check about each shop, and then customers’ reviews on Coating Atlas count for more as a shop collects them. Nobody can pay to change it.

The data score

Each shop earns points from five parts of its profile. Every part comes from data with a recorded source.

PartPointsHow a shop earns them
Verified certification30The shop holds at least one film or coating certification that we have matched to the brand’s own installer locator. A certification claimed only on the shop’s website earns nothing.
Published prices25The shop publishes at least one price for this service on its own website, and the price passed our quote checks.
Brands listed15The shop’s website names at least one film or coating brand it installs.
Profile completeness20Shared equally across: description, opening hours, website, phone number, at least 3 photos, logo.
Years in business101 point per year since the founding year the shop states, up to 10 years.
Total100

How reviews count

Reviews left on Coating Atlas turn the data score into a ranking customers shape. They are blended in step by step, so a new shop with a couple of reviews isn’t lifted (or sunk) by them, and a shop with a long record is ranked mostly on what its customers say:

ReviewsShare of the score from reviews
00%
323%
1050%
3070%
10070%
  • A fair average. Every shop starts as if it had 5 reviews of 4.0 stars. Real reviews pull the rating up or down from there, so two five-star reviews can’t beat forty mostly-five-star ones.
  • Verified customers count more. A reviewer who sends an invoice or a photo of the work gets a “Verified customer” label, and their review counts 1.5×. Only our team sees the proof.
  • Recent reviews count more. A review’s weight halves every 18 months, so the ranking follows how a shop works now.
  • Capped. Reviews never count for more than 70% of the score, so verified facts such as certification and published prices always matter.
  • Shown from 3. A shop’s star rating appears once it has 3 reviews; before that each review is still listed and counted (with the fair average above).

Leaving and inviting reviews

  • Anyone who used a shop can review it from the shop’s page. You confirm your email before it’s published.
  • One review per person per shop. Reviews from the shop itself, or anyone paid to write one, are removed.
  • Negative reviews are published like positive ones. We remove a review only if it’s fake, abusive, not about the shop, or written with a conflict of interest — never for its rating.
  • Shops may invite customers to review them, but must invite all customers, not only happy ones, and may not offer anything in return for a review. Reviews that come from a shop’s invite link are labelled.
  • Shops can reply publicly to any review once they have claimed their listing.

How the score is applied

  • Owners can add facts. Prices and brands entered by a shop’s verified owner count the same as ones on its website. Certification doesn’t: it always needs the brand’s own confirmation.
  • Per service. A shop is scored separately for PPF and for ceramic coating, because published prices count only for the service on the page. A shop that publishes PPF prices but no ceramic prices can rank higher on a PPF page than on a ceramic coating page.
  • Within the city. A city page ranks the shops in that city. When a city has fewer than 3 shops, a separate “Nearby installers” section lists the closest shops within 40 miles, ordered by distance, not by score.
  • Ties. Shops with the same score are ordered by how many priced packages they publish, then alphabetically, so the order doesn’t change at random.
  • Reasons shown. Each listing shows the main reasons for its place, such as “publishes prices” or “3 brands listed”. The shop with the highest score is marked “Top ranked”.
  • Never set by hand. The score is worked out from the current data whenever a page is refreshed, so a corrected price or a newly found brand moves a shop without anyone touching the ranking.

What the score can reach today

One part of the data score isn’t in use yet, and we’d rather say so than fill it with weaker data:

  • Verified certification (30 points): we are still connecting the brands’ own installer locators. Until a shop’s certification is matched to one, no shop earns these points, even if its website says it is certified.

Reviews on Coating Atlas have just opened, so most shops are ranked on their data score for now. As customers leave reviews, the ranking shifts toward them as described above.

What doesn’t count

  • Google, Yelp or any other site’s star ratings and reviews. We don’t store them at all.
  • Payment of any kind, including Featured placement.
  • Advertising, shop size, or how long a shop has been listed with us.
  • Certifications or awards a shop claims but we haven’t been able to check.

Which pages search engines see

Every page can be visited, but we only ask search engines to index pages that have something useful on them. The rules are checked against the data each time it is updated:

  • City pages (such as PPF in Houston): indexed once the city has at least one active shop offering that service. With fewer than 3 shops, the page adds nearby installers within 40 miles.
  • State pages: indexed once the state has at least one active shop.
  • Brand pages for a city (such as XPEL in Houston): only built when at least one active shop in the city lists that brand.
  • Shop profiles: indexed when the profile has a description plus at least one brand or a published price. Other profiles can still be visited but are kept out of search engines.
  • Filters and sort orders never create separate pages; they always point search engines to the main page.

Pages left out of search engines are marked noindex and are not in our sitemap. See how we list shops for where the data comes from.

More about how Coating Atlas works