Coating Atlas

Review guidelines

Reviews on Coating Atlas come from customers of the shops we list. These guidelines explain who can write one, what we publish, and how we keep reviews honest.

Who can write a review

Anyone who has had work done by a shop can review it from the shop’s page or from write a review. Before you send it, you confirm that:

  • you are a real customer of this shop;
  • you are not being paid or rewarded for the review;
  • you don’t work for the shop or a competitor.

Each person can review a shop once (we check by email address), and one network can send at most 5 reviews a day.

What a review may contain

Describe your own experience: what was done, how it looks now, and how the shop handled questions or problems. A review needs at least 80 characters. You can also rate quality, communication, value and timeliness.

Not allowed

  • Fake reviews, reviews of a shop you haven’t used, or reviews written by or for the shop or a competitor.
  • Reviews that were paid for or rewarded in any way, including discounts or free work.
  • Abusive, threatening or discriminatory language.
  • Content that isn’t about this shop’s work.
  • Links to other websites.

Please also leave out prices you were quoted privately.

Email confirmation

After you send a review, we email you a confirmation link. Your review is published only when you open it, and the link works once. If you didn’t write the review, ignore the email and nothing is published. Your email address is never shown or shared, including with the shop.

Verified customers

You can add proof that you are a customer: an invoice or a photo of the work (JPG, PNG, WebP, HEIC or PDF, up to 8 MB). A person checks it, and if it shows you are a customer your review gets a “Verified customer” label. If it doesn’t, your review stays published without the label.

Proof is kept private, used only for this check and never published or shown to the shop. See our privacy policy.

How reviews are checked

Most reviews are published as soon as you confirm your email. A review is held for a person to read first when our automatic checks flag it, for example when it:

  • contains a link;
  • is sent from an email address on the shop’s own domain;
  • comes from a network that has reviewed 3 or more other shops in the last 30 days;
  • repeats the text of another review of the same shop;
  • looks like random characters.

A held review is then published, or rejected for one of these reasons only: it is fake, it is not about the shop, it is abusive, or it was written with a conflict of interest. We never filter reviews by rating or tone, so negative reviews are published like positive ones.

How reviews are shown

  • Your name appears as your first name and last initial, for example “Jane D.”.
  • The review shows your ratings, text, the service, your vehicle if you added it, and the month.
  • Reviews that came from a shop’s invite link are labelled as invited by the shop.
  • A shop’s star rating appears once it has 3 reviews; before that each review is still listed.
  • We only show reviews left on Coating Atlas, never ratings or reviews from Google, Yelp or other sites.

Rules for shops

  • Shops can’t pay to remove, edit, hide or reorder a review. No payment, including Featured placement, changes how reviews are handled.
  • Shops may invite customers to review them, but must invite all customers, not only happy ones, and may not offer anything in return.
  • Shops may not write reviews of themselves or of competitors, or ask staff, friends or family to.
  • Shops can reply publicly to a published review once they have claimed their listing. The reply appears under the review as “Owner reply”, and the shop can change or remove it. A reply never changes the review, its rating or the shop’s score.

How reviews affect rankings

Reviews are part of the Coating Atlas score. The full method is on how we rank; in short:

  • Every shop starts as if it had 5 reviews of 4.0 stars, so a couple of five-star reviews can’t outrank a long record.
  • Reviews from verified customers count 1.5×.
  • A review’s weight halves every 18 months, so recent reviews count more.
  • Reviews make up half of the score once a shop has the equivalent of 10 recent reviews, and never more than 70%.

Reporting a review

If you think a review is fake, paid for, abusive or not about the shop, email hello@coatingatlas.com with the link to the shop’s page, the reviewer’s display name and why you are reporting it. If it breaks these guidelines, we remove it. To change or delete your own review, email us from the address you used to write it.

More about how Coating Atlas works